Repression with a vengeance, prison for ‘insulting’ King, attempt to silence dissent ahead of Grand Prix

Bahrain: new penalty for ‘insulting’ King muzzles activists ahead of Grand Prix
16 April, 2013 – Amnesty International

A move by Bahrain’s government to jail anyone found guilty of insulting the Gulf nation’s King for up to five years is a new attempt to crush dissent before the country hosts the Formula One Grand Prix later this week, Amnesty International has said.

According to state media, on Sunday Bahrain’s cabinet – chaired by the Prime Minister and the newly-appointed deputy Prime Minister, the Crown Prince – endorsed an amendment to Article 214 of the Penal Code, increasing the penalty for offending King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifah or the country’s flag and other national symbols.

The amendment, which has now been referred to the National Assembly, would make such offences punishable by up to five years in prison in addition to steep fines.

The Bahraini authorities claim nobody is detained for peacefully expressing their views and exercising their rights to freedom of expression, but activists have already served jail time for insulting the King. Last November three men – ‘Abdullah ‘Alwi al-Hashemi, ‘Ali Mohammad ‘Ali and ‘Ali Abdul Nabi al-Hayeki – were sentenced to between four and six months in prison for messages posted on their Twitter accounts which were deemed to be insulting to the King. Two have since been released after serving their sentences, but Abdullah Alwi al-Hashemi is still in prison and is due to be released at the beginning of May.

Meanwhile, on 12 March Bahrain’s Public Prosecutor announced on state media that six people had been arrested for defaming the King on Twitter. Separate trials against the six started on 24 March – amongst them 17-year-old Ali Faisal al-Shufa has been charged under Article 214 of the Penal Code for “insulting the King of Bahrain on Twitter”. The latest proposal seeks to use the Penal Code to impose even stiffer punishments in similar cases in the future.

Amnesty International Middle East and North Africa Deputy Director Hassiba Hadj Sahraoui said:

“Increasing the punishment for criticism of Bahrain’s King is a further attempt to muzzle activists ahead of the upcoming Grand Prix.

“The authorities’ reliance on a vaguely-worded criminal ‘offence’ to avoid scrutiny of their record says a lot about their own failures and lack of commitment to reform.

“Amnesty International has repeatedly called on the Bahraini authorities to repeal articles of the Penal Code used to criminalise freedom of expression, including Article 214 which this measure would amend to increase the punishment to up to five years in prison.

“These Penal Code articles are being used to jail dissenters in direct violation of the right to freedom of expression, since they impose restrictions that are not permitted under international law.”

In a briefing released in February, Amnesty documented how, two years on from the 2011 protests in Bahrain, prisoners of conscience remain behind bars and activists continue to be jailed just for expressing their views – whether via social media or in peaceful marches.

Public figures, including those exercising the highest political authority such as heads of state and government, should be legitimately subject to criticism and political opposition, as highlighted by the UN Human Rights Committee. …more